BMW X1 vs. 1 Series: which is better?
Compare BMW 1 Series vs. X1 dimensions, performance, technology, interior and more in our complete review
)
Choosing between the BMW 1 Series and BMW X1 is a pretty nice problem to have, but that doesn’t make it an easy decision.
The premium German manufacturer hasn’t always been at home in the compact car sector, but the 1 Series and X1 prove that it’s more than capable.
These are two small cars that are gorgeously designed, dreamy to drive, and nail it when it comes to space.
Plus, you can find discounted deals on used BMW models if you want to save some money.
Both are great options – but which small BMW is right for you? Find out in our review of the BMW 1 Series vs. the X1.
BMW X1 or BMW 1 Series
Our guide will answer:
Which has the better styling?
Is the BMW X1 vs. BMW 1 Series better to drive?
Does the BMW X1 vs. BMW 1 Series have better tech?
Is the BMW X1 vs. BMW 1 Series more reliable?
What are the BMW X1 and BMW 1 Series dimensions?
BMW 1 Series vs. X1: styling
)
The 1 Series and X1 are easy on the eye – both get the instantly recognisable BMW kidney grille plus the menacing, angular design that we’ve come to expect from the brand.
The BMW 1 Series received a facelift in 2015, with another expected in 2023. All iterations of the model have been sleek and sophisticated so far, with a sporty edge from the almost-estate-feeling shape.
The BMW X1 is a compact car with a bit more height. It fits in well with the current trend for glamorous lifestyle SUVs, featuring a design that will be timeless.
The cars actually look pretty similar, but it’s the X1’s SUV styling that gives it away, so you’ll have to decide which shape you prefer.
BMW X1 vs. 1 Series: what are they like to drive?
)
When you buy a BMW, you expect it to feel great on the road, and neither the X1 nor the 1 Series lets us down.
Both cars get the option of rear- and four-wheel drive, feeling sharp and responsive as a result.
You might find the 1 Series a better drive around town, however, as the steering on the X1 has been reported as feeling heavier.
There’s a range of fuel options too, including petrol- and diesel-powered 1 Series and X1 models, plus a plug-in hybrid X1 for a more efficient drive.
When it comes to running costs, rear-wheel drive models in the X1 lineup are better for fuel economy than the four-wheel options.
You can expect between 40.9mpg to 57.6mpg depending on the X1 you pick. According to official stats, the plug-in hybrid can achieve up to 150mpg.
In the BMW 1 Series, the 116d model offers up to 61.4mpg, so it's a great option for longer drives.
BMW X1 vs. 1 Series: interior and technology
)
When it comes to interiors, the BMW 1 Series will look familiar if you’ve spent any time in a 3 Series Saloon model.
It has the same overall look and many of the same features, but the 3 Series is slightly more plush and offers touches like larger screens.
The BMW X1 is pretty different, with a more simplistic and easy-to-use design. You’ll get Apple CarPlay as standard for smartphone connectivity, plus the iconic iDrive rotary controller that allows you to navigate the top-tier infotainment system.
Some reviews have said that the X1’s interior doesn’t quite measure up to the plush levels of other BMW models, so it might be worth checking out the BMW X4 or X3 if this is a priority.
The 1 Series also offers CarPlay tech as well as Android Auto, which isn’t currently supported in the X1.
BMW X1 vs. 1 Series: bootspace and practicality
)
Both the BMW X1 and 1 Series are practical cars depending on what you intend to use them for.
The X1 is the larger of the two and offers up to 540 litres of bootspace, which is on a par with the Audi Q3 but larger than the Mercedes-Benz GLA.
You also get a lot of extra leg and headroom in the X1, while the SUV stance makes it feel chunkier on the roads.
In comparison, the BMW 1 Series offers up to 380 litres of bootspace. Both models can add to this by dropping the rear seats, so it is possible to fit larger loads if needed.
The 1 Series still has a comfortable and spacious cabin, and would be well-suited for small families or the solo commuter.
It’s by no means a cramped car, but the X1 might be the better choice if space is high on your list of priorities.
Read our in-depth car reviews:
BMW X1 vs. 1 Series: safety and reliability
Both the BMW 1 Series and X1 received a full five-star safety rating from Euro NCAP, meaning that it has enough safety tech to keep you safe and protected on the roads.
The model you choose in each range will decide just how many safety features you get, but each one is nicely kitted-out. You'll also get ISOFIX carseat points in both, for travelling safely with children.
In your 1 Series, you can get front and rear parking sensors, automatic headlights, cruise control and the option of a Driving Assistant pack that includes Blind Spot Detection.
The X1 range also offers front and rear sensors, plus a rear-view camera and dynamic cruise control.
Extras include parking assistance and optional heads-up display.
As for reliability, the X1 receives positive reviews and ratings from drivers and on consumer reliability surveys.
It scores well against other SUVs and has received low levels of complaints and minimal recalls so far.
The 1 Series is also a reliable model, also scoring well on consumer surveys and receiving positive reviews.
BMW X1 vs. 1 Series dimensions:
BMW 1 Series
Length: 4319mm
Width: 1799mm
Height: 1434mm
Boot space: 380 litres
BMW X1
Length: 4500mm
Width: 1845mm
Height: 1642mm
Boot space: 540 litres
Verdict: BMW 1 Series vs. BMW 3 Series – which should you buy?
While the BMW 1 Series and X1 are both sleek, spacious and enjoyable to drive, one might outweigh the other when it comes to your personal needs.
If you want more bootspace, a plug-in hybrid engine or value SUV styling, the BMW X1 might be the better option for you.
Sam Sheehan, our motoring editor, says: "the X1 drives brilliantly and is more practical than its small size might lead you to expect".
Other alternatives that might be worth looking into are the Volvo XC40 and the BMW X2.
For a smaller, sporty choice with a plush interior, the BMW 1 Series could be the one.
This is especially true if you have dreams of moving onto the BMW 3 Series in the future...
Sam says: "They are equally at home commuting between your home and city office, or loading the kids and all their bags in for the school runs".
You could also consider the Mercedes-Benz A-Class, or the Audi A1 as a worthy alternative.
)